English Class 10th Factual Passage 07 Term II

English Language & Literature TERM II

Factual Passage (Solved)

Class 10 Session 2021-2022

Passage 07

Read the passages given below and answer the questions that follow them:

Two-thirds of a century into India’s independence, two aspects of the country’s political evolution are noteworthy. The first is the institutionalization of the periodic transfer of power, peacefully and predictably, recently evident in NDA’s victory earlier this year. But the journey has been much rockier with regard to another critical question: how to direct that power for the broader public good.

While popular commentary on political power focuses on its misuse for private gain or corruption, there has been less attention on the limited ability of political power to translate intentions into outcomes.

The history of independent India is replete with government programmes, ranging from state-owned enterprises to multiple poverty programmes, where political power did have good intentions, but where outcomes have left much to be desired. Critics have put the onus on misaligned incentives and a craven political-bureaucratic nexus.

These factors have their roots in a distinctive feature of India’s political evolution: namely the weakness of the Indian state, hobbled as much by lack of competence as by corruption. Historically the state in India has always been weak and this changed only modestly after Independence. Yes, the state expanded massively; and yes the social composition of the functionaries of the Indian state has changed markedly.

Size and social legitimacy undoubtedly have built state ‘strength’ — the negative power of the Indian state to thwart is certainly manifest. But positive power — the power to do something, to execute programmes and provide basic public goods that are the bread and butter of a state’s responsibilities to its citizens — is still a far cry.

Why strong states develop in some societies and not in others is a complex historical question. One argument is that a strong state can only be built on a firm foundation of nationhood which itself is still a work-in-progress in India. Another view is that warfare laid the foundations of the modern nation state especially in Europe and East Asia.

Historian Charles Tilly famously argued that states make war and war makes states, a reference to the rise of the modern European state after centuries of warfare among hundreds of polities and kingdoms. The ability to wage war successfully requires states to create viable systems of taxation, mobilization and coordination — and only those states that can, survive. But these attributes are also critical for any modern state to deliver public goods and services.

Question.1. How has the transfer of power in India taken place?

The transfer of power in India has taken place quite peacefully and in a democratic manner.

Question.2. Why has the journey been much rockier regarding the second critical question?

Regarding translating good intentions into solid result, the journey has been quite rockier for the government so far.

Question.3. Why has there been less attention on the implementation of schemes?

There has been more stress on talking than, giving attention to the implementation, of schemes by the government.

Question.4. What were the outcomes of the good intentions of the government?

The outcomes of the good intentions of the government were not very encouraging.

Question.5. Whom do critics hold responsible for this poor show?

Misaligned incentives and the nexus between politicians and bureaucrats have been held responsible for the poor show.

Question.6. What has still remained a far cry?

Providing relief to the masses and implementing the welfare programmes has remained a far cry so far.

Question.7. What is another view regarding laying the foundations of the modern nation state?

Another view is that warfare laid the foundations of the modern nation state in Europe and East Asia.

Question.8. What has the historian Charles Tilly argued?

Historian Charles Tilly argues that states make war and war makes states.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!
Scroll to Top